Client work · IBMTampa Electric (TECO)Utility billing2022

Recharging the paper bill

Through strategic design thinking and a user-centered approach, I simplified 7 core components of the paper bill experience, improving clarity and comprehension for over 800,000 customers. The redesign set a new standard for utility communication, aligning business goals with real user needs.

Project statement
Case study · 01
Service period
Jan – Apr 2022
Client
TECO (Tampa Electric & Peoples Gas), via IBM
Role
UX/UI Design, User research
Methods
Industry audit, 30 interviews, co-creation workshop
Tools
Adobe XD, Mural, Zoom, Google Forms, Excel, Slack
Customers servedResidential + Commercial
Bill components simplified: 7800K+
+72%bill comprehension
−40%billing-related inquiries
⁞ 0000800000 7272 4040 2022 ⁞
TECO · Paper bill redesign · Residential + Commercial
Final design
TECO paper bill redesign
The problem

Confusing layouts and inconsistent formats on TECO's paper bills were driving a surge in customer service calls.

What I did

Led a full redesign of the bill grounded in research, stakeholder alignment, and a workshop where customers built their own ideal bill.

The result

A modular, consistent bill system across residential and commercial, gas and electric. 72% better comprehension and 40% fewer billing calls.

01Context

A bill people need, but can't read

TECO customers faced ongoing challenges understanding their statements because of unclear layouts, inconsistent formatting, and overwhelming information. That led to confusion around payment details and energy usage, and a steady rise in customer service inquiries.

Despite how essential a utility bill is, there was a real lack of user-friendly communication, and customer feedback wasn't part of the design process. That created a gap between what customers needed and what the bill was actually showing them.

The goal: turn TECO's paper bill into a clear, consistent, user-focused tool that improves understanding and cuts down service inquiries, by simplifying structure, standardizing formatting, and putting key details where people expect them.
How might we

…give 800,000+ customers a bill they can understand at a glance, so they don't have to call to figure out what they owe or why it changed?

Design process
Empathize, Define, Ideate, Prototype, Test
02Research

Benchmarking the industry, then listening

I started with an in-depth industry analysis of how leading utility providers design and structure their statements. That surfaced common best practices: clear payment summaries, visual usage breakdowns, and standardized layouts that make bills easy to read.

Comparing those benchmarks to TECO's existing bills made the gaps in clarity, consistency, and experience obvious, and gave the redesign a strong foundation.

70+
Paper bills reviewed
Statements from leading utility providers
35+
Digital bills reviewed
Online and in-app billing experiences
70+
PDF versions downloaded
Downloadable bill formats compared side by side

30 interviews across every side of the bill

We interviewed residential and commercial customers as well as internal stakeholders. That mix gave us everyday bill recipients alongside the people who manage and deliver the billing process, and it's where the pain points, priorities, and opportunities for the redesign came from.

Interview breakdown by customer segment
03Current bill audit

Page by page, where the bill breaks down

Before designing anything, I went through the existing bill one page at a time to pin down exactly where customers were getting lost.

Header & marketing conflicts

Breaking through the noise

  • Social media links and marketing messages compete with critical account information
  • Redundant payment information appears twice, creating confusion and visual clutter
  • Essential account details get lost among promotional content
Original bill, page 1
Dense content structure

Information overload

  • A wall of text makes important charge definitions hard to scan and understand
  • Contact information lacks visual hierarchy and clear organization
  • Critical information is buried inside long paragraphs
Original bill, page 2
Usage & billing presentation

Data clarity

  • Complex billing calculations have no visual guidance to help explain charges
  • The usage history graph is undersized and underused for showing consumption patterns
  • Key metrics get lost in dense numbers
Original bill, page 3
Table structure & readability

Rate complexity

  • Dense, technical rate information with no visual aids or clear categories
  • Multiple rate schedules with no clear navigation or user context
  • Technical detail overwhelms anything practical
Original bill, page 4

Breaking down the current bill

Analyzing the original bills surfaced clear patterns, which became six core component categories. These mapped the current state of the bill and set up everything that came after.

Payment information (pay stub)
  • Critical transaction elements
  • Account authentication details
  • Payment method options
Cost structure
  • Charge breakdowns
  • Rate applications
  • Visual cost representations
Information architecture
  • Contact and understanding documentation
  • Educational materials
  • Reference guides
Customer segments
  • Residential templates
  • Commercial layouts
  • Service-specific variations
Account summary
  • Usage overview
  • Historical data
  • Promotional integrations
Specialized programs
  • Budget billing options
  • Solar program details
  • Program enrollment information
04Synthesis

What we heard, and the rules it gave us

We synthesized insights from customers and internal stakeholders across residential, commercial, and operational perspectives. Affinity mapping the feedback surfaced recurring themes and clarified the core problems the redesign had to solve. That became the foundation for every design decision after it.

Theme 01
Data clarity & transparency

Customers want to easily identify and understand the information on their bill statements.

“Only a portion of the information I care about most is on the front page.”
Theme 02
Awareness

Customers want to be fully aware of what's on their energy statements, and they look to TECO to communicate that information.

“I want to know what I currently don't.”
Theme 03
Avoidance

Customers won't engage with their statements because of a lack of knowledge, unless there's a noticeable inconsistency.

“I do not understand my service charges and I request support when fluctuations are significant.”
Theme 04
Empowerment

Customers are open to changing how they use energy when the bill gives them clear, trustworthy information to act on.

“I would be willing to change my behavior if I was confident that I was making the correct decision.”
Affinity map · four themes from 30 interviews
User experience pillars

Six tests every component had to pass

01
Scannability
Content can be read and understood in the shortest amount of time.
02
Digestibility
Information is easy to understand without needing a lot of explanation or help.
03
Actionability
Clear actions and support, so customers always know their next step.
04
Transparency
Honest content that consistently delivers what it promises, building trust and credibility.
05
Insightfulness
Accurate, personalized insights that help customers understand their own usage more deeply.
06
Relevance
Content that fits the customer's current time, period, or circumstances.
05Who it's for

Four customers, four very different bills

We turned the research into personas for the key residential and commercial segments. Each one captured different goals, pain points, and habits, and grounding decisions in them kept the redesign tied to real people.

Dave
Traditional customer focused on bill clarity and cost management
Residential gas
“I want to be able to see my past usage to easily compare my bill.”“What is contributing to the largest part of my gas bill and what are options to manage it?”
Dave persona board
Diego
Tech-savvy environmentalist looking for detailed consumption data
Residential electric
“Paper bill does not give enough specific information about my energy consumption.”“I don't know what appliances are drawing the most energy.”
Diego persona board
James
Restaurant chain owner managing multiple locations and meters
Commercial electric
“Bill versus meter, a constant issue is identifying the exact meter and area this bill is tied to.”“My bill covers many items… that's difficult at times to summarize in total charges.”
James persona board
Cindy
Enterprise facilities manager who needs complex billing solutions
Commercial electric
“Meters are not identifiable by location.”“For multiple buildings that use one address: need more space in bill to identify physical service area and specific location.”
Cindy persona board
06Co-creation

Customers built their own bill

I turned the insights into a library of modular bill components, from payment summaries to usage visualizations, designed to be flexible, consistent, and easy to use.

To test and refine them, we ran a co-creation Enterprise Design Thinking workshop with customers, who assembled their ideal bill layouts in real time. It showed us directly what worked, what confused people, and how the pieces fit together.

Persona review
Groups reviewed their persona so every activity was done through that person's eyes.
Pain points
Captured the persona's pain points with today's bill, then talked through the themes.
Component voting
Voted on components from TEC/PGS and other utilities, and discussed what made them work.
Build the bill
Decided what goes on each page, where it sits, and how to show it.
Component discussion
Reviewed a bank of research-backed components: what they liked and didn't.
Playback
One customer per group presented their newly designed paper bill.
Component library

The building blocks customers worked with

07Building the bill

One system, four bill types

Each workshop group built a bill for their segment. These are the layouts they landed on and the reasoning behind them. They became the blueprint for the final design.

Residential electric

Residential
01
Amount Due, Due Date, and a detailed Bill Summary are front and center so customers can find what they need to pay.
02
Account Number, Address, and Contact Us stay in the same spot on every page, so customers can identify their bill and share the right info when they call.
03
Detailed Energy Charges and Delivery & Supply Charges share a page so usage is explained in one place.
04
Energy Comparison and Energy Saving Tips come later, with pre- vs. post-pandemic callouts in threes to explain why a bill changed.
Page 1
Page 2
Page 3

Residential gas

Residential
01
Amount Due, Due Date, and Account # are prominent, with a concise Bill Summary for quick payment.
02
Detailed Energy Charges and Energy Comparison live on page two, in the same order as the summary on page one.
03
Energy Saving Tips and other good-to-knows sit to the right of the detailed charges to call out insights.
04
Nothing on page three, to keep the bill simple.
Page 1
Page 2
Intentionally
blank
Page 3

Commercial electric

Commercial
01
Meter nicknames in the Meter Read section on page one, so customers can tell their meters apart.
02
A QR code to pay on page one, for an easy jump to online billing.
03
Charge definitions go on the final page, where they can be referenced next to the Detailed Bill Summary.
04
The bill gets more detailed as it goes, building understanding of what makes up the charges.
Page 1
Page 2
Page 3

Commercial gas

Commercial
01
Content aligns to the letter folds (the dashed lines).
02
Bill Summary, Amount Due, Meter Number, and Due Date take the first visual space on the bill.
03
Energy Comparison sits right below the summary, with Payment History in the charts for an end-to-end view, color-coded to match.
04
Page two holds the granular details: Detailed Billing Summary, Energy Charges, enrolled programs and savings, and payment options. Nothing on page three, to save paper.
Page 1
Page 2
Intentionally
blank
Page 3
08The work

From workshop wireframes to a finished bill

We built high-fidelity prototypes of the future-state bill, updating existing components and adding new ones based on everything we'd learned. Feedback from the co-creation workshop shaped multiple rounds of iteration and testing, until the design was clear, consistent, and ready to implement.

Wireframe → final

Front of the bill

Drag the handle to compare. Amount due, due date, and account details now lead the page. The usage chart is bigger and easier to read, and the marketing that used to compete with account info is gone.

Wireframe Final bill front
WireframeFinal
Final design

The new paper bill

Redesigned bill
09Outcomes

Clearer bills, fewer calls

The redesign gave customers a bill they could actually follow, and gave TECO a consistent system across every customer type.

Customers servedPost-redesign
800K+
residential and commercial customers on the redesigned bill
7core bill components simplified
4bill types in one system

Business impact

ImprovementReductionRating
+85%
+72%
+65%
−40%
85%
Charge comprehension
Usage understanding
Payment processing
Support calls
Customer satisfaction